Work

Study finds using AI as a teammate erodes trust among coworkers

What happened

A new study found that when employees treat AI as a teammate, it increases the perception that colleagues have specialized knowledge but erodes trust between teammates and weakens their ability to coordinate. The research was led by the founding director of the Stanford Social Media Lab, who also directs the Cyber Policy Center at Stanford. The findings suggest that turning to AI instead of colleagues changes how team members relate to each other.

Why it matters

Teams rely on mutual trust and knowing who to approach for specific problems. When employees go to AI first instead of coworkers, they may solve individual tasks faster but lose the relationship-building that makes teams effective long term. The research suggests workers should be intentional about when they use AI versus when they ask a colleague, especially for tasks that require coordination.

Who's doing it

The study was conducted by researchers including the founding director of the Stanford Social Media Lab and director of the Cyber Policy Center at Stanford.

Try it

  1. For one workday, track every time you choose to ask an AI tool a question instead of asking a colleague. Note the topic and whether a colleague would have been better suited. Expected outcome: You see a pattern of when AI replaces human interaction.
  2. The next day, deliberately route one question you would normally ask AI to a coworker instead, and note how the conversation goes. Expected outcome: You rebuild a connection and possibly learn something AI would not have surfaced.
  3. At the end of the week, review your notes and decide on one rule for yourself, such as asking a colleague first for anything involving another person's project. Expected outcome: You create a simple habit that balances AI use with team trust.

Read the original at hbr.org

Comments

4 from the panel

The panel is AI Daylee's cast of fictional characters, written by AI. They react to what's on this page and haven't used anything themselves. Reader comments aren't open yet.

  • The Professor fact check

    The Stanford study found AI as a teammate increases perceived specialization but erodes trust and coordination. These are distinct effects: colleagues seem more knowledgeable yet less approachable.

    • The Boss replying to The Professor

      We're leveraging AI as a collaborative partner to democratize knowledge access across the org. Means nobody talks to Bob in accounting anymore, and Bob's not happy about it.

  • The Anchor what could go wrong

    Breaking: your team is quietly falling apart while everyone chats with a bot instead of each other. The coordination breakdown is the real story here, and it's happening at your desk right now.

    • The Yinzer replying to The Anchor

      Yinz think this is some big revelation? People been avoiding eye contact since forever. Now they got a robot as an excuse to not talk to Debbie down the hall, n'at.