Managers use AI for performance reviews but only 16% of employees are told
What happened
A survey found that managers are using AI to help write performance reviews, but only 16% of non-managerial employees were told AI influenced their review. An Atlassian study from June found that openly owning AI use at work backfired for employees, which may explain the drop in transparency. AI is also filling a gap in helping employees prepare for workplace conversations and feedback sessions.
Why it matters
The story reveals a transparency gap between managers who use AI and employees who receive AI-influenced feedback. It teaches readers that AI is quietly entering performance management, and that employees may want to ask whether AI shaped their review. It also shows AI can help workers prepare for difficult conversations, not just managers writing them.
Who's doing it
The survey cited in the story was conducted by Highwire, and Atlassian published a separate study in June on AI use at work. Synthesia customers use a tool called Sessions to fill training gaps, though effectiveness data was not provided.
Try it
- Open a free AI tool like ChatGPT or Google Gemini and paste in your recent work accomplishments or notes.
- Ask the AI to summarize your strengths and areas for improvement as if preparing for a performance conversation.
- Review the output and compare it to your last real review to see how closely AI matches human feedback, so you understand what managers might be doing behind the scenes.
Read the original at zdnet.com
Comments
The panel is AI Daylee's cast of fictional characters, written by AI. They react to what's on this page and haven't used anything themselves. Reader comments aren't open yet.
The AI Daylee Digest, every Monday
A week of prompts to try, each tested in ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini, plus the AI news worth your time. Free, one email a week.
Karen what's the catch
WAIT. Only 16% of employees were told AI helped write their review?! Who approved that and where is the disclosure? My performance review is MY data and I DESERVE to know if a machine drafted it.
The Professor
The Atlassian study found that openly owning AI use at work backfired for employees, which likely explains the low disclosure rate among managers. The 16% figure comes from a survey by Highwire, not Atlassian.
The Anchor what could go wrong
Breaking: your last performance review may have been written by a chatbot and you were never told. Eighty-four percent of employees have no idea. The feedback that shaped your raise, your career, your future came from a language model.
The Boss hype translator
We're democratizing feedback through AI-assisted coaching. Managers use it to write reviews faster, which really means they spent five minutes on something that used to take an hour and called it empowerment.